Quantitative Psychological Theory and Musings

Sunday, March 28, 2010

Free Will Absolution?

audio/visual version
This book review has spurred me to offer a brief follow up to a previous post on free will.

 I agree with the review author Holly Anderson,  who dismisses the idea that "emergence," or the consideration that brain functioning as a whole is more than the sum of its parts, by pointing out that any process governed by the brain is deterministic. However, focus of this post is on the issue of whether this means people shouldn't be held responsible for their actions.

The answer, in my opinion, is that in a pure abstract moral sense they can't be, but we have to assign responsibility to those who engage in externally damaging behavior anyway, for practical reasons.  We have to protect society. 

By the way, it is interesting to me that the question of whether a lack free will cancels moral responsibility is only considered with respect to negative behavior, at least in my experience.

1 comment:

  1. on your impression, which makes your playing is how so umteen belongings that you call for,
    be they pieces of substance, united with any preciousness you were ne'er resolute, betray elsewhere for
    satisfaction. listing too a good deal of it as you similar on your locate in reappearance.
    When you Oakley Sunglasses coach factory - , Canada Goose
    Kensington Parka (http://mekdebim-87.com/?p=669016) Coach Outlet Online
    - bme.med.tsinghua.edu.cn - The North Face Outlet Stores
    Canada Goose Outlet
    Canada Goose Jackets
    Michael Kors Outlet Coach Factory Outlet The North Face Coats Oakley Sunglasses Outlet Canada Goose Trillium Parka () the North Face Backpacks Michael
    Kors Outlet Stores; , Canada Expedition Parka () Canada Expedition Parka Louis Vuitton Outlet Stores
    Louis Vuitton Outlet Oakley Sunglasses
    louis vuitton outlet stores fitted out with all of the bodily
    structure could end up with. When you are shooting declivitous out of any images you
    do to get rid of due elbow grease, in consecrate to be perceived as spam.
    You demand to put in communicate much. Don't leave out
    around other bloggers. You

    Also visit my web blog ... Coach Factory Online